• The issue has been fixed and hopefully you can post screen shots again
  • Hi Guest Just in case you were not aware I wanted to highlight that you can now get a free 7 day trial of Horseracebase here.
    We have a lot of members who are existing users of Horseracebase so help is always available if needed, as well as dedicated section of the fourm here.
    Best Wishes
    AR

Handicap Class Droppers

I think there will always be a conflict in terms of class when dealing with handicaps because as we've all noted you will very rarely find a low weighted contender in a handicap who has a siginficant class advantage over higher weighted horses. That's just the reality of such races. By and large the higher weighted horses will have earned that weight by their achievements. Not always winning achievements granted, but the point remains you will not find many low weights with sparkling credentials based on class alone.

Another overview I've started looking at this week is based on criteria I think plays a part in VDW's Handicap Hurdle method and after research I've found areas where the majority of winners in these races come from. Of course you still need to pick the right one from three or sometimes more options.

In this overview for the race Black Bamboo won today it's interesting to see how those with the recent runs fared when looking at where they were in the weights and the ranks of class they last ran in. I sorted the view on days since last ran for this view.

The 3 I had in my book had class largely on their side but had plenty of runners with more recent efforts ahead of them and the 2 most recent runs were the first 2 home.

And if you look at the handicap hurdle Love From Verona won, the same questions arise on low weighted runners. The 4 lowest weights carried had run in lower class races with 2 of them winning LTO. One of those horses won with 10-0 in a class 11 race whilst the other won with 10-12 in a class 10 race.

Note some of the non runners are still included so ignore those.

Screenshot 2026-11-14 at 23.19.34.png
 
Something I noted from VDW's reply to HH of Cranleigh is below and it is relevant to the question of days since a horse last ran on a racecourse.

"VDW REPLIES: Whatever method of evaluation is used to search out likely winners, it is always useful to run a cross-check using some other means. On one occasion I illustrated a method which used as basic elements the best four placings from previous two outings, combined with the five most recent runs - 'Speed Is No Use Without Form Says, Dutchman' 23/8/79 - and it is this to which I believe H.H.Cranleigh refers.

Finding a means of evaluation that suits you as an individual is important, because however successful a method may be, if it does not fit in with you, nothing can make it work to the best advantage.

In my view it is always useful to have any number of ideas available provided you do not put so much wood in the picture, that you fail to see the trees.

How long a horse has been off the course has a significant bearing especially when coupled with good form. Nothing is foolproof and horses differ widely. Some require almost no work at all to bring them into condition while others need pushing all the way.


It is noticeable that many winners have recent race experience and if this is coupled with significant form it adds greatly and is a factor of real value. END VDW"

It's also worth noting that in this letter VDW clarified the process for The Old Fella race crosscheck and it is as I thought, with the initial stages being the best four placings from the last 2 outings of the field combined with the 5 most recent runs. So one set of qualifiers combined with another before totalling the last 3 form figures. A runner does not have to be in both the placings and most recent runs.

He also provided another simple method several years earlier that also makes use of days since last ran. The letter is below and would have been useful yesterday for Cheltenham finding the winner of the 2nd most valuable suitable race but not the main race where the fav had not run since March.

"The remaining two letters from F.Chester and R.Smith can be covered by putting forward the outline of a very simple method. Consider the two races on the card having the highest prize money. On the course study the boards, but in the betting shop you will have to wait for a show. If the favourite is at reasonable odds and the field not too large, select the first five in the betting.

From these sort out the three that have been off the course for the shortest time. You can use the three highest race numbers from returns if you like, but watch for any that ran a few days previous and are not listed. Call the three horses A, B, and C and split them into two bets (A being the first quote) A B and B C. Stake two points A and one point B for the first bet and one point each B C for the second. Each of the two bets are
kept separate and applied to a simple staking method. If A or C wins that particular series wins. If B wins both succeed.

I will give a few illustrations to show points to watch out for from the 'pull out' of the same issue as the letters (Jan 17).

Race 1387. Favourite is odds-on and not a race to bet on with this method as Dikaro Lady was among the three. On the other hand, note race 1432. The even money favourite Tommy Joe does not come in the three, so a bet favoured A B winning with Mac Vidi 4-1. The same applies to race 1418 where again A B wins with Turk 11-4. Note also race 1399 Stockton, 1-45, Jan 8. Rigorous has a 10lb penalty so leave it out. Here B C wins with Burelor 9-1. Note also race 1393, Fontwell. In this race four come out, but it does not require much thought to leave out St Gawain. Both A B and B C win with Cabar Feidh 100-30.


I have outlined just the bare bones of the method leaving readers to use a little initiative. Those who studied my previous contributions will appreciate this is just another way to reduce the field and it will no doubt help them to arrive at just one selection for the race. The process is very simple. For Mr Chester, I hope it shows there is always another way round a problem."
 
Fontwell 12:30 Western Cross and Belfrina

Cheltenham 3:10 This race is filled with horse making their seasonal debuts and lots of recent of runners who largely didn't show much in those runs. The exceptions in the latter list are Pioneer Pete, Mister Ursus and The Hardest Gezzer but on balance I think I'm going to leave this race. Dan is mob handed in this race with a mix of promising younger horses and perhaps jaded older runners.
Put is this way last year I was very confident that Alexei would win this race, but there's nothing with the recent profile of that horse in this race today so I'll give it a miss and roll my eyes if one of the 3 recent runners named above goes and wins it.

Navan 12:40 Mr Caulfield, Tropical Twist and La Roca Lass are my 3 against the field here and at the prices I can make a book. Mr Caulfield would surely have won at Carlisle just a few days ago and if you look at it's previous runs it's not hard to conclude it was on the job at Carlisle. The 2nd last run does not tell the whole story as the horse had no problems with laying up with the leaders with 4 furlongs to go but the jockey eased off and let the horse coast home in his own time. It could have finished way closer to the 4 horses in front of it that day. It's true level of form was shown at Carlisle in a better race than this, it was just bad luck the horse crashed through the last when clearly going the better as it moved to the front. Hopefully there are no mishaps today back in Ireland.

Navan 1:50 I'm leaving Mart Lane out here and going with Better Times, Matt Connor and Paddy's Milestone.
 
idiotic mistake in the first at Fontwell. Western Cross and Marhaba Prince ran in the same better race last time and went off 100/30 fav and 7/2 2nd fav respectively. One of them ran it's race, the other did not.

Classic case I see all the time. I know that scenario and I ignored it simply to include a horse who drifted like a barge and was clearly not expected to do well even after a recent flat run and wind op.

If you think about there was no valid reason to discard one of 2 horses who ran in the same race last time where only one of them ran near to form and they were the front 2 in the market that day. Today the one who ran his race went off 5/4 fav and the other 9/1.

What a plonker.
 
Mr Caufield ridden way out of it's ground and goes down by just over a length to LTO winner and lower weighted Crypto Crash who had an Erin figure of 3 and also raced within the last 14 days.

Think today is gonna be a washout. 2 losing races from my 3 so no chance of getting ahead without upping stakes.

Which of course is what VDW said he did within certain boundaries. And the eternal question persists of why would you need to have a staking plan if you claim to get 85 to 90% winners at all manner of prices?
 
Well that late decision to back Highland Legacy just cost me any profit gained from the 1:50 at Navan which turned out to be a book bet at just under 3/1.

And hey look another winner with an Erin of 3 and a low weight to boot.
The balance of class that VDW refers to really should have been more specific, especially as he said he sees handicap races as happy hunting grounds with his method.

Weight is the balance influencer.

It simply has to be in handicaps by their very nature.

Try and find many examples of very low weighted horses with form in better class races than the opposition in handicaps.

You won't.

Screenshot 2026-11-15 at 14.08.29.png
 
Authoceltic carried the lowest weight in the race of 10-7.

Was 2nd in the 2nd lowest class race in the field LTO but was carrying 11-13 that day beaten comfortably by 2 lengths by a horse carrying 1 lb more who had won 3 of it's previous 4 races. Hence the low Erin figure today.

Larzac fran 2nd today having won LTO in the lowest class race of the field. Again an Erin of 3. But only carrying 5 lb less and first time over fences.

The first 3 places were filled by horses with the lowest Erin figures in the race.

Highlands Legacy was one of the 3 most consistent, but Erin figure was 4th lowest rating in the field.
HL was carrying more weight than last time but down in class.
First run of the season, though did win a lesser race first time out last season. AR of 117 in a 217 race really should have warned me it was no easy task today to give weight away. When he won a class 262 race he carried 12 lbs less than today.
 
Just for the record here are my 2 overviews of the Greatwood. I still don't want to bet in the race but there are several runners in there with low Erins and weight advantages from the first 6 in the betting. The result will no doubt prove interesting.

Screenshot 2026-11-15 at 14.29.52.pngScreenshot 2026-11-15 at 14.30.14.png
 
Unless anyone knows of any others, I can only find 12 examples of handicap hurdle selections he gave.

6 of those were from the specific method for those races, 5 were given as per his original 3 most consistent from the first 6 of the forecast approach and Ever Smile was the best bet/next best method (whatever that was).

Screenshot 2026-11-15 at 19.41.03.png
 
Last edited:
Ever Smile was a handicap hurdles selection, Tufnel Tufnel, though of course one of VDW's best bet/next best six and might not be what you are looking for. There are plenty of hurdles races among the main VDW selections but I can't think of another handicap hurdle to add to your list.
 
Back
Top