• The issue has been fixed and hopefully you can post screen shots again
  • Hi Guest Just in case you were not aware I wanted to highlight that you can now get a free 7 day trial of Horseracebase here.
    We have a lot of members who are existing users of Horseracebase so help is always available if needed, as well as dedicated section of the fourm here.
    Best Wishes
    AR

Handicap Class Droppers

Tufnel Tufnel


Many thanks Pitmatic Pitmatic
I was just about to post that the old link from 2016 no longer worked.
That gives me some reading to do whilst I sit out the racing action today.

I’d be lying if I wasn’t a little miffed about not backing De Deli Counter yesterday because of 3 lbs in weight.
And also backing Rate Me at Market Rasen but not yesterday when it won at 3/1 despite being one of 2 probables.

But that’s the game I suppose.
 
"I guess the end game, from your friends point of view, is when they decided they'd learned enough from the ' how to grow books' and started growing them."

No. It was when he'd achieved enough that the time and commitment involved in hoping to go one better next year was too much for the possible additional pleasure of a 1st prize. Who knows? If he had continued, got his 1st, he might have been for chysanthemums what Bernard Jones was (and for me remains) for sweet peas.
 
But he did refer by name to what both PKing & Beacon Light had in front of them, though only by anonymous “not much opposition” for Mr Kildare.

Hi Tufnel Tufnel,

The term "not much opposition" I take to mean exactly that.
The returned S.P's were 8/11 Mr Kildare, 3 Oisin Dubh, 6 Silvine and 12/1 and more the rest. So in effect it was basically a 3 horse race and therefore only 2 horses with any realistic chance of beating Mr Kildare.

But VDW could have been referring to the "class" of opposition from an official ratings point of view.
From the weights for that seasons Sweeps Hurdle, Monksfield was top weight at 12-0, Beacon Light 11-13, Prominent King 11-3, Drumgora 9-13 and Oisin Dubh 9-6. Silvine was not entered but would have had the same weight as Oisin Dubh by my reckoning.
Mr Kildare was not entered in any Handicap as far as I know, so would not have had an official rating.
 
Looks like Frankies Dream returns to Newcastle today, Tufnel Tufnel .

I don't think the trainer has found the easiest race for it, but if it wins, I wouldn't be surprised.

It won't be carrying my money though. Regards
An almost identical run to the last visit here, but managed to get in front at the finish this time.

Class of finish: -3lbs under par, so a reliable race for form.
 
Think I definitely missed one here. I could see it was the class/form horse, but the consistency and Erin put me off when really they should not have done. This was a huge drop in class from both last 2 runs so the consistency totals were never going to be low as she was outclassed in those runs behind Blue Bolt and Love Dynasty. But she was unbeaten on the AW and the 3rd last race was a win in a better class of race than any of these had in their recent form. Ryan Moore also last rode her when she won that race at Ascot too.

Should have been on Kon Tiki today really.

Screenshot 2026-11-19 at 23.23.06.png
 
Ascot 2:30 Shortlist is Williethebuilder, Brenda's Asking, Move It Like Minnie and Fasol.
Williethebuilder was one of those rare occasions where a horse went up in class and still carried a big weight. That was in the same race as Brenda's Asking, Brenda's Asking, Move It Like Minnie and Fasol and Fasol, though the latter has run since and narrowly won.
It's tempting just to go with just the low weighted Move It Like Minnie and Brenda's Asking, but I think it is dangerous to leave out Williethebuilder given the drop in class.
Move It Like Minnie is the only one of the three carrying less weight than last time with capable claimer Amber Jackson-Fennell on board. The horse also has much less dead weight in the saddle compared to Williethebuilder given his jockey's normal riding weight. Though that hasn't stopped many of his mounts winning such races recently. J.Burke obviously has a low riding weight anyway so his mount is only carrying a few lbs in lead.
I do think these 3 hold the key to the race and it's a shade over evens to back all 3 in a book. But I'm not going to play in the race because I can't confidently get it down to 2 runners let alone 1.
Move It Like Minnie, Brenda's Asking and Williethebuilder are the 3 likely to win, but I'll leave it alone.

Catterick 1:43 Shortlist is Speed Davis, Noonetellsmenothin and Jeteye. The latter is technically 3rd class rated but the difference between that horse and the 2nd rated is a mere £160 or so and given he won well last time and has less weight today being unpenalised on CJ race rules it would be crazy to scrub him out.
Given the conditions today and where they all sit in the weights Jeteye and Speed Davis look the pair to dutch.

Chepstow 1:32 Lejo Du Seuil and Can You Hear Me are the 2 shortlisted. CYHM's recent form doesn't fit the low weight profile where as LDS's upped in class and now one of the top weights down in class does fit the profile required. Nice jockey change too.

Obviously there are a lot of novice form horses in here and my reading of the 6 examples VDW gave for the HH method was to put such horses to one side until they had shown form in a handicap. That can have drawbacks as often horses who have shown little in novice events from just a few runs can turn out to be very well handicapped and several yards associated with such horses have runners here today. In fact LDS showed his best form in his first handicap last time.

I was reading the Marvex books Pitmatic Pitmatic kindly put up yesterday and there is a chapter on Handicap Hurdles. Whilst Marvex doesn't really detail much method in that chapter he does touch on several things that VDW clearly took heed of and borrowed for his own letters and articles. For example the point about the difference between dead and live weight and also not letting novice or conditions form into handicap hurdle races until those horses have shown they can show form in handicaps. Which kind of confirms what I had deduced from VDW's HH method examples. He skipped over several higher class runners who had been running in non handicaps so far.

Anyway, I think Lejo Du Seuil is the correct favourite here so I'm backing him and it's just a case of if any of the even more lightly raced runners have yet to show their real hand yet.

Similar points arise in the 2:42 at Chepstow. Several switching to handicaps from good yards. Northwest Passage opened up 2/1 for his first handicap hurdle last week on the back of a good run on the flat behind the easy November Handicap winner Alfred Wincham. NP drifted out to 100/30 but still won pulling a cart from a mark of 96 with 11-9 and carries a 7lb penalty today with a mere 3lb more and is 6lb well in on future handicaps. He doesn't fit into the filters as I have them in respect of class over days since last run. But going on the 4 runners who have run in the last 28 days he looks to have an excellent chance to follow that win up and justify the handicapper's reaction to Southwell.

I'm going to back Northwest Passage and take the chance that there are no other handicap blips in the race.

Looking at the indicated races from the SIAO method one of those is covered in the Ascot 2:30 race and that's a watching brief.
Of the other races Ben Solo looks like it has a very good chance to repeat last year's win, but again I think it doesn't have everything go it's way.
One of the first 3 in the Ascot main race at 1:55 will probably win it but again there are things not right for all 3. Perhaps Crebilly might follow up of the higher mark but he's not know these days for running up two on the trot and the other two look better opponents than last time.

I'll stick with my 3 bets above.
 
Last edited:
And that's why you don't bend the rules. Northwest Passage didn't fit the initial filters. Travelled well but beaten by 2 from bigger yards.

Meanwhile I threw away a better than evens shot at Ascot where I was sure I had the winner covered in the horses he did perfectly fit the filters.

Very annoying day really.

1 winner from 3 bets and a winning evaluation thrown down the drain whilst breaking the rules for a 6/5 shot at Chepstow.
 
Those Marvex booklets show someone of both intellect and experience but also how far we have come since the 1940s and 1950s in respect of ability to access and handle large quantities of data extremely quickly. From that perspective it really is a different world from when Marvex, and even VDW three decades later, were active in writing about analysing races. For all that, whether most of us do any better in terms of profitability than the "old timers" is quite another matter.
 
Those Marvex booklets show someone of both intellect and experience but also how far we have come since the 1940s and 1950s in respect of ability to access and handle large quantities of data extremely quickly. From that perspective it really is a different world from when Marvex, and even VDW three decades later, were active in writing about analysing races. For all that, whether most of us do any better in terms of profitability than the "old timers" is quite another matter.
Reading them again it is very evident VDW borrowed not only many ideas from Selby, but also I feel he even imitated his style of writing. Though clearly VDW discarded some of his views such as never touching chase events or just betting in handicaps.

I did wonder if he compiled his own handicap ratings along the same lines as in the Marvex books, but it shouldn't be under estimated how time consuming that was even in the 70s and 80s using paper and pen trying to cover 6 horses a race.

If you use Drumgora as benchmark, Prominent King on a handicap basis was 19 lb superior but went down by 5 lengths bringing that to 14 lbs.
Decent Fellow gave 17 lbs and 3.5 lengths to Drumgora just before that which makes DF 21 lbs superior to Drumgora and 7 lb superior to Prominent King. But in the Erin Decent Fellow was giving 7 lbs to Prominent King bringing them level pegging on a handicap basis.

Where they do seem to differ is in their definition of form. Marvex is clear it is the best recent handicap rating he has awarded a horse. But it is not so clear that VDW worked that way.

He obviously adopted the class via prize money to the winner idea from the Marvex books for races and then came up with the AR, rather than the other way round which is how he presented it to SCHB readers. But Marvex clearly didn't hold much faith in placings themselves, certainly not in the way VDW appears to.

As I noted earlier the Marvex view on Handicap Hurdles and also the games trainers play in placing their horses before a win attempt seems very relevant to VDW. The jockey riding weights is still a very valid point and I think played a big part in the low weighted examples VDW gave, and it played out today in the race at Ascot where the rider on the winner Move It Like Minnie was able to take off weight from his back requiring no lead in the saddle, unlike the 2nd horse who's very good claiming rider has to ride with top weights with a fair bit of lead in the saddle regardless of his claim.

The novice/conditions only form issue is also evident, and I think I was wrong to discard that so easily having spotted it in the 6 examples in the first place.
 
Apparently when the 76/77 NH season ended, Beacon Light was around 7 to 10 lbs inferior to Sea Pigeon.

But by the time of the Otley in 78 surely Beacon Light would have edged up the handicap to close that gap?
Even so it seems had the Otley been a handicap, Sea Pigeon would have been giving Beacon Light a few lbs and not the other way round.
 
Back
Top