cpw
Yearling
Sure let's ask.It makes you wonder why this one has been backed into Fav. Other than a link to the late Barney Curly and BHA having dropped
View attachment 150845
Purchased at the 2023 Horses in Training for a Grand
Pedigree
https://www.tattersalls.com/cat/autumnhit/2023/1535.pdf
What does AI mke of this onecpw is it a red herring or a genuine gamble
When comparing Many A Year and Gentle Ellen, there are distinct strengths and weaknesses for each horse that can help determine which is more suited for this race.
Form & Recent Performance:
- Many A Year: Showed signs of improvement in his last race, finishing fourth at Wolverhampton, which was a step in the right direction after several unplaced efforts. However, he has yet to win a race from 11 starts, which suggests he struggles to finish strongly.
- Gentle Ellen: Her recent form has been inconsistent, finishing sixth in her last race at Haydock, but she has 3 career wins, all at 6f, which is encouraging. She has also proven to bounce back after poor runs.
Course & Distance (C&D) Experience:
- Many A Year: Has no previous runs at this course or over this specific course and distance combination. His experience at 6f is limited and his record shows no wins.
- Gentle Ellen: Has won over both course and distance. Her C&D record (3 runs, 1 win) is a major advantage in this context. She is comfortable at this track, which can be a key factor in competitive handicaps.
Going & Conditions:
- Many A Year: Has placed twice on similar going from 3 attempts, which shows he handles these conditions fairly well. While he’s yet to win, he’s shown potential on similar surfaces.
- Gentle Ellen: Has a broader experience with going, having won on varying conditions from good to soft. Her 3 wins and 4 places from 17 runs on similar going show she's versatile in these conditions.
Distance:
- Many A Year: Has placed twice over the 6f distance but hasn’t yet managed a win in 7 attempts, indicating he may struggle to finish races strongly at this trip.
- Gentle Ellen: Has 3 wins from 10 starts at 6f, a solid strike rate of 30%, showing she is well suited to this distance and can compete strongly.
Class & Handicap Experience:
- Many A Year: Has yet to win in this class or at this level of handicap. His recent fourth-place finish suggests he’s improving but remains winless in similar circumstances.
- Gentle Ellen: Has previously won in this class and is dropping to a workable handicap mark. Her past victories in similar handicaps demonstrate her capability to succeed in this company.
Overall Consistency:
- Many A Year: Despite his recent improvement, he remains winless in 11 starts, and while he's placed a couple of times, he hasn’t shown the level of consistency needed to inspire full confidence.
- Gentle Ellen: While not flawless in form, her 3 career wins and consistency in placing in the past suggest she's more reliable overall. She has a 15% strike rate across all flat races, which is respectable.
Conclusion & Preference:
Gentle Ellen is the clear preference over Many A Year. She has the advantage in several key areas:- C&D-winning experience.
- Better record on similar going.
- Stronger form over 6f.
- Proven ability in this class and at this handicap level.



In truth who knows its part of the pleasure and the price. !
