This might not work but i was often overwhelmed by what"the average OR is a huge factor now into my considerations."
For me, the major advantage we have compared with the VDW years is the ready availability of ORs, T tacker, and I too use the average OR extensively as (usually) a better way of assessing the strength of a field than VDW's. Not that I don't use his, too.
I expect what what you say about trainers is right, though never having met one I have no first hand knowledge.
I am sure you weren't unique in dismissing VDW's letters at the time. His claims were extraordinary and as far as is known he never provided any proof.

This might not work but i was often overwhelmed by what @ARAZI91 would show me....![]()
Totally agreeThe basic rating which he first identifies works very well. The second part with the weight is the piece de resistance.
Proform cost ? It’s about value to the user - it’s a huge tool with many different parts that I doubt many use or even understand, it’s a bit like the Sky subscription in that if you want sport then you have to pay for it all. I really only use the “system builder “ in the form book to create race cards and interrogate past form - now we sectionals inc (at an extra cost ) this is optional and I haven’t had chance to use it yet , but I will do.
Only certain people can see it i believe ...... clicked on it it myself and you get this ... "You do not have permission to view this page or perform this action " . No problem with that i might add !
Thanks for that S simon boardmanOnly certain people can see it i believe ...... clicked on it it myself and you get this ... "You do not have permission to view this page or perform this action " . No problem with that i might add !
" When is the Handbrake Off " !! My good mate at work part owns horses with J Parr and he always quotes that to me when i start talking about Ratings etc " Is there a Handbrake Off Rating " ? To muddy the waters he tells me that J Parr has owners that just love a day out and dont overly care if the horse wins or not , a nice evening out at Windsor inviting all their mates . This infuriates J Parr as he is trying to expand and attract new owners and "Winners " are the name of the game for himI was just reading a story about why lesser tennis tournaments had match fixing, And the player said the smaller the tournament with prize money the more likely fixing going on as the money not as important.
Well you could say the same about horse racing the prize money is so poor at the bottom level that the lower you go the more likely none triers
and you don't really get it right till you go to really top value races.
Which would make complete sense in any sport really.
So in this day and age no matter how you look at it and this is the biggest point MONEY talks in all walks of life sadly i know but fact.
So when you throw everything else out the window surely the two most important things now in form study wither we like it or not are prize money and gambles.
I know its hard to adjust our thinking to reading form and just not think this horse hasnt got the best form to the one we fancy but surely if money coming for some thing against your fancy you must start to worry some what.
There might be no knowing reason you see in it but its there staring you in the face gamble and if yours is drifting the more it drifts i feel the more you should be worried.
I know people will say but drifters win horse races and gambles get beat regular, But i would say regular is strong word but if you switched that round other way, drifters get beat and gambles win you could use a lot stronger word than regular now especially in higher class races.
Me too Simon and likewise no problem. I did use to enjoy interacting withOnly certain people can see it i believe ...... clicked on it it myself and you get this ... "You do not have permission to view this page or perform this action " . No problem with that i might add !

Everyone who has done proper studies in this reckons more weight the better, they have a class edge, I haven’t churned the data like them, but I have a belief from creating ratings that the reason they have a class edge is not necessarily that they are better horses by definition(higher OR in most cases), although a factor I think the real reason is the BHA scale is too narrow a range and for every pound they are giving away they should be giving between 1.2 and 1.4 pounds away, of course this is related to OR and sometimes higher rated young horses have lower weights thats another reason those horses are advantaged also they have the class edge.Over the years some of my best Form finds have come off the back of a losing bet and my poste mortem examination seeking to understand where i had gone wrong. I think in this game we are all learners and occasionally being prepared to accept this can turn todays loss into future gains. This self honest questioning works in many different ways including enabling swerving losers or overcoming a long held bias which leads to backing some additional winners.
Any changes to my MO are only implemented after much thought and investigation but a more recent example which has proved a good move is after many years overcoming ( in part ) my prejudice against horses under large physical weights. I used to take the easy out and would not back any horse carrying more than 9-4 and fair dues this worked well enough on balance but around four years ago i began to notice an increase in top rates off my ratings winning with 9-5 > .
As ever i thought just a blip but i paper proofed the future examples and the trend continued. This triggered a renewed interest into seeking and identifying the ins and outs of WCA Weight Carrying Ability and using my findings from this as a required proven filter i finally started allowing myself to back some of those in the 9-5 > 9-13 range which to date has proved a profitable move.
I still feel unable to bet those in the 10-0 > 10-4 range but maintain an open mind and who knows the future. At present regardless of any positive findings i do not feel comfortable about risking my wedge on these 10-0 plus horses and comfort zones are important and also need to be accommodated as part of the whole, or at least this has been my experience.
Me too Simon and likewise no problem. I did use to enjoy interacting withARAZI91 on other parts of this forum and hope he is well. As i recall besides having advanced knowledge of the game he also had a good sense of humor when the banter was flying.
![]()
I guess this depends on who and what " proper studies " mean. ? Stat based findings can be helpful but taken at face value also misleading. I prefer to look at the back form of individual horses and the circumstances they succeed or failed under a big physical weight.Everyone who has done proper studies in this reckons more weight the better.