Six years since my last post on this thread - doesn't time fly
. Anyway I thought there may be some interest in this attempt at the second elementary mechanical procedure from the 25 Aug 1979 letter Sports Forum, SCHB.
After reviewing yesterday's result (posted elsewhere) I found that my Prof Frank George chart showed the best possible reason for the favourites unexpected failure, Ascot 5.20. That was from no 5. down all the runners were weight favoured and Live In The Moment and Call Me Ginger had both dropped over 14lbs from their last outing. That ties in with the view from the book 'Sprint Handicapping Explained' that even ounces in sprints can make a difference. That's my explanation anyway
.
Pontefract going forecast GF -G watered rain) RP verdict Modern News (8 pundits agree 5 oppose)
4.05 Market expected 08.40* no's 1, 7, 5 indicating a win restricted to these. This is a class 1 stakes so no OR for standard but market or time could be considered.
1*. 6* = 2/1 mkt Modern News 9 tips (BF D2). LTO 29 -1lb =cls W Buick up. 2/4 -nse* led kept on final furlong strongly challenged headed finish. (C Appleby rates 27)
2. 2* = 15/2
3. 2* = 15/2
4. 4* = 11/1
5*. 4* = 11/2 Magical Morning (D4). LTO 39? -3lbs +1cls? R Havlin up. 21/29 -13L? ridden edged right never on terms.
6. 0* = 50/1
7*. 5* = 5/2 Alflaila 3 tips. LTO 17 -8lbs=cls J Crowley up. 2/8 - 1 1/2L* ridden outpaced rallied went 2nd no match with winner
Comment: I can see no reason not to support the early market favourite or for safety dutch with Alflaila.
ATR form verdict in comparison.
Modern News may be the best horse in this line-up having already won in Listed company and after a narrow defeat at Windsor last month, but he has to give 11lb to ALFLAILA and that may be a big ask. A winner at Ascot on his return this season, he was slowly away in the Jersey Stakes at the Royal meeting and then finished second at Newmarket in a similar race last time, which looks solid form. Magical Morning and Dubai Icon are others to take seriously on their best efforts, though their lack of consistency recently is a concern.
Top Tip: ALFLAILA (7)
Watch out for: MODERN NEWS (1)